New Scoring System [5 of 5 - ★★★★★] [4 of 5 - ★★★★] [3 of 5 - ★★★] [2 of 5 - ★★]
Old Scoring System [5-Star - ★★★★★] [4 ½-Star - ★★★★☆] [4-Star - ★★★★] [3 ½-Star - ★★★☆] [3-Star - ★★★] [2 ½-Star - ★★☆] [2-Star - ★★] [1 ½-Star - ★☆] [1-Star - ★] [½-Star - ☆] [0-Star]
Alphabetical Anime Review List | How I Rate Anime
5 of 5 – ★★★★★ Chobits CLANNAD (TV) Eden of the East Last Exile Toradora
4 of 5 – ★★★★ Candy Boy DNA2 End of Evangelion Fruits Basket Howl’s Moving Castle Maria Holic Kashimashi: Girl Meets Girl Nijuu Mensou no Musume Place Promised in our Early Days, The Video Girl Ai
3 of 5 – ★★★ A Certain Magical Index Dual! Parallel Trouble Adventures Kimi ga Nozomu Eien: Next Season K-ON! Maid Guy Oh! My Goddess (OVA) Porco Rosso Sora o Miageru Shojo no Hitomi ni Utsuru Sekai
2 of 5 – ★★ DearS Someday’s Dreamers: Summer Skies
5-Star – ★★★★★ Five Centimeters Per Second – 97.2% ef – a tale of memories – 95.8%
4 ½-Star – ★★★★☆ Haibane Renmei – 93.5% Girl Who Leapt Through Time, The – 92.4% Metropolis – 92.2% Kanon – 92.0% Kurau: Phantom Memory – 92.0% Fullmetal Alchemist: The Movie – 91.7% Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, The – 91.1% Angelic Layer – 91.0% Azumanga Daioh – 91.0% Rumbling Hearts – 91.0% Shakugan no Shana – 91.0% Cat Returns, The – 90.6% Cardcaptor Sakura – 90.5% Fullmetal Alchemist – 90.5% Koi Kaze – 90.5% Gunslinger Girl – 90.0% Spirited Away – 90.0%
4-Star – ★★★★ Princess Mononoke – 89.4% Cardcaptor Sakura 2: The Sealed Card – 88.9% Kiki’s Delivery Service – 88.9% Kannagi – 88.4% Air (TV) – 88.0% MoonPhase – 88.0% Evangelion 1.0: You Are (Not) Alone – 87.6% Ah! My Goddess: The Movie – 87.2% My Neighbor Totoro – 87.2% Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind – 87.2% Neon Genesis Evangelion – 87.0% Blue Drop – 86.8% Wind: a breath of heart (TV) – 86.8% Ouran High School Host Club – 86.3% Voices of a Distant Star – 86.1% Please Twins! – 86.0% Minami-ke – 85.8% School Days – 85.8% Shion no Ou – 85.8% Cowboy Bebop: The Movie – 85.6% Scrapped Princess – 85.5% Baccano – 85.3% Stellvia – 85%
3 ½-Star – ★★★☆ I”s Pure – 84.7% Shakugan no Shana: The Movie – 84.7% Infinite Ryvius – 84.5% Someday’s Dreamers – 84.5% World of Narue, The – 84.5% Idolmaster Xenoglossia – 84.2% Genshiken (Season 1) – 84.0% Kaleido Star – 83.5% Kurenai – 83.2% Bokusatsu Tenshi Dokuro-chan – 82.9% Fushigi Yugi – 82.5% Ballad of a Shinigami – 82.4% Murder Princess – 82.4% Castle in the Sky – 82.2% Ai Yori Aoshi – 82.0% Magic Knight Rayearth – 82.0% Cowboy Bebop – 81.5% Lucky Star – 81.5% Mokke – 81.1% Ah! My Goddess (TV) – 81.0% Akira – 80.6% X – 80.5% Ah! My Goddess: Fighting Wings – 80.0% Air: The Movie – 80% Midori Days – 80.0%
3-Star – ★★★ This Ugly Yet Beautiful World – 79.0% Myself; Yourself – 78.9% Bokura ga Ita – 77.4% Sky Girls – 77.4 Whisper of the Heart – 77.2% His & Her Circumstances – 77.0% Kannazuki no Miko – 76.0% Pretear – 76.0% Legend of Himiko – 75.5% Kamisama Kazoku – 75.3% Sketchbook: Full Colors – 75.3% Cardcaptor Sakura: The Movie – 75.0%
2 ½-Star – ★★☆ Doujin Work – 74.7% Fushigi Yugi: Eikoden – 74.4% Yozakura Quartet – 73.7% Mahoromatic – 73.5% Spice and Wolf – 72.6% Origin: Spirits of the Past – 72.2% Mamotte Shugogetten – 72.1% Happiness! – 71.1% Nagasarete Airantou – 71.1% Diamond Daydreams – 71.0% H2O: Footprints in the Sand – 70.5% Ajimu: Kaigen Monogatari – 70%
2-Star – ★★ Nanatsuiro Drops – 69.5%
1 ½-Star – ★☆ Fushigi Yugi OVA 1 & 2 – 67.2% Special A – 65.3% Seto no Hanayome – 62.1% Love Hina – 62.0% Umisho – 61.6%
1-Star – ★ Uta-Kata – 59.5% Akane Maniax – 59.4% Girls Bravo – 56.5%
½-Star – ☆ Moetan – 52.6%
0-Star Love Hina Again – 47.2%
List of Anime by Score
New Scoring System
[5 of 5 - ★★★★★] [4 of 5 - ★★★★] [3 of 5 - ★★★] [2 of 5 - ★★]
Old Scoring System
[5-Star - ★★★★★] [4 ½-Star - ★★★★☆] [4-Star - ★★★★] [3 ½-Star - ★★★☆] [3-Star - ★★★]
[2 ½-Star - ★★☆] [2-Star - ★★] [1 ½-Star - ★☆] [1-Star - ★] [½-Star - ☆] [0-Star]
Alphabetical Anime Review List | How I Rate Anime
New Scoring System
5 of 5 – ★★★★★
Chobits
CLANNAD (TV)
Eden of the East
Last Exile
Toradora
4 of 5 – ★★★★
Candy Boy
DNA2
End of Evangelion
Fruits Basket
Howl’s Moving Castle
Maria Holic
Kashimashi: Girl Meets Girl
Nijuu Mensou no Musume
Place Promised in our Early Days, The
Video Girl Ai
3 of 5 – ★★★
A Certain Magical Index
Dual! Parallel Trouble Adventures
Kimi ga Nozomu Eien: Next Season
K-ON!
Maid Guy
Oh! My Goddess (OVA)
Porco Rosso
Sora o Miageru Shojo no Hitomi ni Utsuru Sekai
2 of 5 – ★★
DearS
Someday’s Dreamers: Summer Skies
Old Scoring System
5-Star – ★★★★★
Five Centimeters Per Second – 97.2%
ef – a tale of memories – 95.8%
4 ½-Star – ★★★★☆
Haibane Renmei – 93.5%
Girl Who Leapt Through Time, The – 92.4%
Metropolis – 92.2%
Kanon – 92.0%
Kurau: Phantom Memory – 92.0%
Fullmetal Alchemist: The Movie – 91.7%
Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, The – 91.1%
Angelic Layer – 91.0%
Azumanga Daioh – 91.0%
Rumbling Hearts – 91.0%
Shakugan no Shana – 91.0%
Cat Returns, The – 90.6%
Cardcaptor Sakura – 90.5%
Fullmetal Alchemist – 90.5%
Koi Kaze – 90.5%
Gunslinger Girl – 90.0%
Spirited Away – 90.0%
4-Star – ★★★★
Princess Mononoke – 89.4%
Cardcaptor Sakura 2: The Sealed Card – 88.9%
Kiki’s Delivery Service – 88.9%
Kannagi – 88.4%
Air (TV) – 88.0%
MoonPhase – 88.0%
Evangelion 1.0: You Are (Not) Alone – 87.6%
Ah! My Goddess: The Movie – 87.2%
My Neighbor Totoro – 87.2%
Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind – 87.2%
Neon Genesis Evangelion – 87.0%
Blue Drop – 86.8%
Wind: a breath of heart (TV) – 86.8%
Ouran High School Host Club – 86.3%
Voices of a Distant Star – 86.1%
Please Twins! – 86.0%
Minami-ke – 85.8%
School Days – 85.8%
Shion no Ou – 85.8%
Cowboy Bebop: The Movie – 85.6%
Scrapped Princess – 85.5%
Baccano – 85.3%
Stellvia – 85%
3 ½-Star – ★★★☆
I”s Pure – 84.7%
Shakugan no Shana: The Movie – 84.7%
Infinite Ryvius – 84.5%
Someday’s Dreamers – 84.5%
World of Narue, The – 84.5%
Idolmaster Xenoglossia – 84.2%
Genshiken (Season 1) – 84.0%
Kaleido Star – 83.5%
Kurenai – 83.2%
Bokusatsu Tenshi Dokuro-chan – 82.9%
Fushigi Yugi – 82.5%
Ballad of a Shinigami – 82.4%
Murder Princess – 82.4%
Castle in the Sky – 82.2%
Ai Yori Aoshi – 82.0%
Magic Knight Rayearth – 82.0%
Cowboy Bebop – 81.5%
Lucky Star – 81.5%
Mokke – 81.1%
Ah! My Goddess (TV) – 81.0%
Akira – 80.6%
X – 80.5%
Ah! My Goddess: Fighting Wings – 80.0%
Air: The Movie – 80%
Midori Days – 80.0%
3-Star – ★★★
This Ugly Yet Beautiful World – 79.0%
Myself; Yourself – 78.9%
Bokura ga Ita – 77.4%
Sky Girls – 77.4
Whisper of the Heart – 77.2%
His & Her Circumstances – 77.0%
Kannazuki no Miko – 76.0%
Pretear – 76.0%
Legend of Himiko – 75.5%
Kamisama Kazoku – 75.3%
Sketchbook: Full Colors – 75.3%
Cardcaptor Sakura: The Movie – 75.0%
2 ½-Star – ★★☆
Doujin Work – 74.7%
Fushigi Yugi: Eikoden – 74.4%
Yozakura Quartet – 73.7%
Mahoromatic – 73.5%
Spice and Wolf – 72.6%
Origin: Spirits of the Past – 72.2%
Mamotte Shugogetten – 72.1%
Happiness! – 71.1%
Nagasarete Airantou – 71.1%
Diamond Daydreams – 71.0%
H2O: Footprints in the Sand – 70.5%
Ajimu: Kaigen Monogatari – 70%
2-Star – ★★
Nanatsuiro Drops – 69.5%
1 ½-Star – ★☆
Fushigi Yugi OVA 1 & 2 – 67.2%
Special A – 65.3%
Seto no Hanayome – 62.1%
Love Hina – 62.0%
Umisho – 61.6%
1-Star – ★
Uta-Kata – 59.5%
Akane Maniax – 59.4%
Girls Bravo – 56.5%
½-Star – ☆
Moetan – 52.6%
0-Star
Love Hina Again – 47.2%