Comments on: CLANNAD: After Story – Episode 22 [END]

By: Pradeep

Pradeep — Mon, 23 Aug 2010 19:34:55 +0000

PLEASE READ MY CONCLUSION TO THE STORY . I AM SURE YOU WON’T HATE.

Give a reasonable thinking to it. please

I guess I understood somehow why Nagisa didn’t die. In some of the episode of Clannad After story (episode 8) Yukine Miyazawa , who tries to end the gang war that her brother Kazuto dream of. She says that if a person gets hold of the light orbs(balls) then he/she could grant a wish. Thats why when Ushio died Tomoya wished that she could be saved and wished that everything would had been normal had he not met Nagisa. So indirectly he wished for everything to be normal. Then the girl says to the robot that she cannot leave that planet cause she is bound to it as it is another dimension to people of earth’s feeling. Thus she asks Robot/tomoya to return and decide. Tomoya decides to meet Nagisa once again and thus his true dream is restored finding himself beside Nagisa during childbirth and everthing ends smoothly.Although in the third part Fuko finds the girl from the other world/Ushio left all alone under a tree. So i think that the robot on the other world sacrificed himself and send the girl instead after learning its his daughter. That means Tomoya sacrificed himself. So their could be 2 ending as I guess. The 1st one is more reasoning although it might also mean that Tomoya and Nagisa went off somewhere for a walk or the girl came running as she usually does near the hospital.

By: mac

mac — Thu, 12 Aug 2010 14:18:40 +0000

well to be honest i think the girl and the robot in the snow is an imagery, the girl represents the daughter and how she isnt loved by anyone with the robot symbolizing a father-like person. when her world disappears, i see it as the end of the world of misery that tomoya has gone through all his life and that he finally finds peace when he dies. (the imaginary world dies as he dies) so he us thus finally in heaven with his wife and child and they are reunited so in a way it has some aspect of the afterlife in it which makes it such as beautiful anime. i feel that this anime is trying to send a message across that whatever bad experiences and losses we have on earth, is nothing compared to the joy that we will feel when we are reunited with our loved ones on day after death.

By: Martin

Martin — Thu, 20 May 2010 22:10:26 +0000

Another explanation could also be the alternate worlds we heard about.

In one of the worlds, Nagisa and Ushio does die, however, in another world, they both live.

By: shaira

shaira — Thu, 29 Apr 2010 05:16:27 +0000

clannad~after story~ ending:
Ushio does die. Nagisa did die. However, Clannad has a reset ending. The girl in the other world is an older Ushio, and the bear-robot is Tomoya. In the end of the anime, TIME GOES BACk to when Nagisa gives birth to Ushio, but she lives this time. It has a happy ending. Fuko comes out of her coma for real at the end, too.

By: deterh

deterh — Wed, 05 Aug 2009 11:53:41 +0000

I think the story is that tomoya had to go through this hardship to make himself a better person.
I still really dont understand this though, after nagisa dying you learn to think ok thats ok theyre living a happy life ushio and tomoya after he realises he needs to be a father figure to her and protect her.
(i especially liked they way they said they were off to nagisa’s picture ) then when Ushio dies i kinda just thought …. “what the hell”. I mean they just completely hate tomoya, i was pretty sad at the end and to have that all turned back into a ending where nagisa is alive, its almost , i dunno “surreal” yo put in terms. You know what i mean ur kinda like… “but theyre dead” ^^

anyway is it just me or isint there 50 episodes? i thought i saw that somewhere, what are the about?